[Mark Ulrik]

Garry Puffer Wrote:

Mark Ulrik Wrote:

Garry Puffer Wrote:Here is an oddity. When the Carcano in the Backyard Photographs is compared to the Carcano in the National Archives, they do not appear to be the same weapon.

What can explain this?

BYP and NA Carcanos Compared.png

That's the mistake Jack White made. You can't just take two random photos of the same object and expect the proportions to match.

Are these the same windows?

sixthfloor.jpg

Not sure what your photo example is supposed to show, sorry.

But I understand that you fall back on the "Jack-White-was-not-a-photo-expert" argument. Good to know. That way you don't have to discuss any of the differences. Clever. All due to perspective. Got it. Thanks.
BYP and NA Carcanos Compared.png

Congratulation on finding "differences". My example shows the TSBD sixth floor windows from 2 different angles. Notice how the features don't line up, just like in your example.

Here's a home assignment for you: Find two different photos of the Carcano, taken from different angles or with different cameras, where all the features line up. Can you do that?