[Ben Holmes]

(08-01-2016, 12:10 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  

Ben Holmes Wrote:Until you can gather up enough courage to answer the question of how to differentiate shots heard from the Railroad yard from shots that came from that Grassy Knoll...

Courage !!!

Are you kidding me.......?

I have no idea if I could tell the difference between a shot from the Knoll (picket fence) and the Railroad yard - maybe, maybe not. Probably more likely if the railroad shot was over the the south and probably not if the shooter was in the yard behind the Knoll fence.

Not only is it a silly question, it has no relevance - it does not matter what I think.

Au contraire!!! The fact that you've been running from this question shows that you know you're fighting a losing battle. Because in order to defend McAdams' tabulation - YOU ABSOLUTELY MUST BE ABLE TO DIFFERENTIATE between the Railroad yards and the Grassy Knoll.

And you've just admitted that you cannot.

Such amazing cowardice!

Now, since you've admitted that you cannot tell the difference... unless you can produce a statement from McAdams that details how HE
was able to do what you cannot, then YOU MUST ADMIT THAT THE TABULATION IS PROVABLY WRONG.

My best guess is that you won't... you'll simply turn silent again.

But if you EVER try to defend the McAdams tabulation as accurate again, I'll simply label you a liar.

(08-01-2016, 12:10 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  What is significant (though proves nothing) is that the VAST majority of witnesses stated that ALL the shots they heard sounded like they came from the SAME location.

This is quite typical... try to change the topic.

You cannot differentiate between the Railroad yard and Grassy Knoll from the TSBD entrance... therefore, BY YOUR OWN WORDS - you have no way of placing such a witness in the "Railroad" list, instead of the "Grassy Knoll" list.

And more important, you realize this - which is why you've been running like a coward for days on this issue.

(08-01-2016, 12:10 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  There are no lies, just your ridiculous and frankly off the wall interpretation of plain English and your frankly juvenile cryptic comments. Now I am a smart guy Holmes and extremely well educated, but some of the stuff you write just mystifies me - it really does.

Yes Patrick, it's ABSOLUTELY a lie to put a witness into a category that you cannot show they belong in.

Until YOU can differentiate between a Railroad yard location, and a Grassy Knoll location - then YOU are dishonest in placing such a witness outside of the Grassy Knoll list.

YOU ARE PERSONALLY DISHONEST - because you're defending the dishonest tabulation of McAdams...

So yes, Patrick... there are lies being told.

(08-01-2016, 12:10 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  And all this no doubt is about your silly theory that some one fired from the Southern "knoll" area - and that he was one of about 5 or 6 shooters who got off maybe 7 shots......yeah right.

Change of topic again...

Got caught lying, and it hurts...

(08-01-2016, 12:10 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  My education has been wasted.....? You have no basis to make that judgement  and what a illogical and juvenile statement it is.

Indeed, it most certainly HAS been wasted ... you can't see the simple point I'm making.