[Ben Holmes]

(12-02-2016, 03:51 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  

(11-29-2016, 03:27 PM)Ben Holmes Wrote:  (20) Oswald had the cab drive past his residence, dropping him off down the road. 

This is sheer speculation that isn't based on the evidence... chances are quite good that Oswald never even took a taxi. Indeed, this particular evidence would tend to show that it wasn't Oswald who took the taxi.

Once again we see the presumption of guilt, then an attempt to force the evidence into supporting this 'guilt'.

I am not aware of any credible evidence to suggest that Oswald did not take a cab. However I accept that it is possible that Whalley gave a ride to another white male, who resembled Oswald. But then how did Oswald get back to his rooming house?

Of course you're not aware of any contradictory evidence for your theory... you simply put it out of you mind, and refuse to even acknowledge it. (Such as your recent lying about answering the only question asked... in the thread on the head wound.) 

You probably haven't a clue who Darryl Click is...

And you've probably never heard of David Edmond Knapp - the guy that Whaley actually identified...

Oswald probably got back to the rooming house the way that the earliest witnesses and photos showed... picked up in a station wagon.

(12-02-2016, 03:51 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  It is  a bit like saying we can't rule out three ice bullets being fired in Dealey Plaza - all missed and melted. Sure you can't prove that did not happen, but I think we know that did not happen.

Au contraire... I'm using EVIDENCE and explaining the known EVIDENCE in this case... you are the one simply speculating away...
 

(12-02-2016, 03:51 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  This is just one of those things that defies logic......of all the places that Whalley could have taken his passenger - it just happens to be right by Oswald's rooming house and right before when the housekeeper says Oswald comes into the property in a rush.......what a coincidence.....

It wasn't, of course, "right by Oswald's rooming house". It was more than a block away, and the guy who got out of the cab starting walking South... Oswald's apt was North.

Go ahead, Patrick, deny any of these details...

And explain why you claimed to have answered the only question raised in the head wound thread, then pretended to be surprised that I was referring to the only question in that post...

Or run again. Who cares???