[Ben Holmes]

John McAdams Wrote:

Ben Holmes Wrote:You cannot ‘misremember’ and describe what it’s never been possible for you to have seen.

Nonsense. False memories are quite common.

But in Baden’s case, he was not there at the autopsy, so it’s not a “memory” issue. It’s a “use of sources” issue.

Once again, John shows a rather appalling lack of understanding.

NO-ONE, absolutely no-one… at the autopsy saw the interior chest photos. Indeed, no-one at the autopsy SAW ANY PHOTOS WHATSOEVER.

So John is being quite silly to suggest that if only Dr. Baden had been at the autopsy, he’d have correctly remembered a non-existent photo.

Nor is it a “use of sources” issue… Dr. Baden ABSOLUTELY AND INDISPUTABLY saw each and every one of the existing autopsy photographs.

HE’S SPEAKING FROM ABSOLUTE AUTHORITY.

And he lied. Because there’s no such photo. It’s really just that simple.

John *STILL* cannot offer a credible scenario for Dr. Baden to be “remembering” not only a non-existent photo, but able to “describe” that it was out of focus.