[Ben Holmes]

(08-04-2016, 06:19 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  

(08-02-2016, 03:38 PM)Ben Holmes Wrote:  "... but there is no evidence that an "A. J. Hidell" existed." (WCR 292)

And since you've refused to retract your lie that McAdams' tabulation is "unassailable" - indeed, absolutely REFUSE to debate the issue, you're a proven liar ... so I'll just point it out again, and move on...

Absolute nonsense. Will you STOP calling me a liar !!! its is thugish and ignorant.

I stated simply that I had not seen ALL the McAdams categorisations, but I made it very clear what the key point was.

You stated very clearly that the McAdams' tabulation was "unassailable" - yet now you ADMIT that there's one provable error. That means that you lied.

Because you refuse to retract your false claim - it's clearly a lie - and that makes you a liar. Why should I stop pointing out WHAT IS ABSOLUTELY TRUE?

If you can show how the McAdams' tabulation is both in error and "unassailable" at the same time, then I'll be happy to apologize for labeling you a liar.

But I won't hold my breath...

(08-04-2016, 06:19 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  Unfortunately for you your intellectual rigour in this matter seems to be severely lacking, but that should be no no surprise to anyone as you have consistently demonstrated your tunnel vision on this subject. Your need to be right about every little piece of information - most of which is barely relevant - outweighs athe contribution you make to any overall debate.

And yet, I am completely and totally correct in the assertion that McAdams' tabulation is provably wrong. That makes you the liar on this issue, since you absolutely refuse to retract your false claim.

(08-04-2016, 06:19 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  As I stated to you last week - keep calling me a liar and I will pay little attention to your web site and you can enjoy near solitude.

And I've pointed out before what these threats do to me... absolutely nothing. I'm sure that you'd be quite happy if I failed to point out lies told by WCR Supporters - it would allow you to post material that may convince somone... but if you want to convince anyone on THIS forum, you'll do it with the evidence.

I'm not surprised that you ran time and time again from the question about the Railroad yard... I'm sure you figured out that you'd be indicting McAdams when you finally answered... as indeed you did.

(08-04-2016, 06:19 PM)Patrick C Wrote:  Hidell was an alias used by the lone assassin. Period.

So what's your explanation for Mr. Jenner's statement? Surely you must have one...

The Warren Commission lied, and you cannot refute that simple fact.